Setauket Homes For Sale Open House Sun, Feb 6, 5 PM UTCPlease verify times due to COVID-191 / 15$1,349,000Single Family Home For SaleComing Soon5BEDS5TOTAL BATHS5,000SQFT41 SetalcottSetauket, NY 11733Â New Listing - 2 weeks online1 / 15$568,000Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS186 Lower Sheep Past RoadSetauket, NY 11733Â New Listing - 2 weeks online1 / 30$1,499,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS5TOTAL BATHS14 Indian Valley RdSetauket, NY 11733Tinker Bluff SubdivisionNew Listing - 2 weeks online1 / 16$525,000Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS34 Mayflower LaneSetauket, NY 11733Heatherwood SubdivisionNew Listing - 3 weeks online1 / 36$499,990Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1,593SQFT16 Yorktown RoadSetauket, NY 11733Â New Listing - 3 weeks online1 / 36$549,999Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1,500SQFT6 King Arthurs CourtSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 11$799,990Single Family Home For SalePending5BEDS4TOTAL BATHS3 Homecoming PlaceSetauket, NY 11733Gatedthree Village Club Subdivision1 / 27$515,000Single Family Home For SalePending2BEDS3TOTAL BATHS72 Thompson Hay PathSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 32$1,200,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS4TOTAL BATHS2,800SQFT9 Chestnut AvenueSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 35$1,789,000Single Family Home For SaleActive6BEDS6TOTAL BATHS6,062SQFT1 Lemark CourtSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 26$499,000Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS9 Storybook LaneSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 35$849,999Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS4 Hawkins AvenueSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 35$1,683,000Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS5TOTAL BATHS11 Shore DriveSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 31$585,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS385 Main StreetSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 23$499,000Condo For SaleActive2BEDS3TOTAL BATHS88 Erik Drive #88Setauket, NY 11733The Lakes Subdivision1 / 36$2,500,000Single Family Home For SalePending5BEDS5TOTAL BATHS9 Mill River RoadSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 35$649,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1,992SQFT210 Old Town RoadSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 32$899,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS1,926SQFT5 Linda LaneSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 35$550,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS190 Lower Sheep Pasture RoadSetauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 31$849,000Single Family Home For SalePending5BEDS3TOTAL BATHS3,232SQFT91 Bennetts RoadSetauket, NY 11733Â See All Stauket Homes For Sale TweetShareSharePin0 Shares