Muttontown Homes For Sale New Listing - yesterday1 / 31$1,355,000Single Family Home For SaleComing Soon3BEDS4TOTAL BATHS180 E Coachman PlaceMuttontown, NY 11791Muttontown Knolls SubdivisionNew Listing - 2 weeks online1 / 28$4,390,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS6TOTAL BATHS5 Westgate RoadMuttontown, NY 11791Â New Listing - 3 weeks online1 / 34$999,000Single Family Home For SaleActive0.62ACRESNASSAUCOUNTY2 Buckingham CourtMuttontown, NY 11791Stone Hill At Muttontown SubdivisionNew Listing - 4 weeks online1 / 34$2,188,000Single Family Home For SalePending5BEDS5TOTAL BATHS4,105SQFT2154 Ironwood RoadMuttontown, NY 11791Â 1 / 14$1,499,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS204 Brookville RoadMuttontown, NY 11545Â 1 / 32$2,499,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS5TOTAL BATHS22 Serenite LaneMuttontown, NY 11791Â 1 / 34$7,990,888Single Family Home For SaleActive7BEDS10TOTAL BATHS375 Mill River RoadMuttontown, NY 11771Â 1 / 36$10,998,000Single Family Home For SaleActive9BEDS12TOTAL BATHS13,000SQFT393 Mill River RoadMuttontown, NY 11771Â See All Muttontown Homes For Sale TweetShareSharePin0 Shares