skip to content

Middle Island Homes For Sale

📊 Middle Island Housing Market Update: July 2026

The Middle Island housing market recorded a median sale price that rose during the 12 months ending July 2026. Compared with the preceding 12-month period, new listings increased, closed sales increased and average inventory increased.

The clearest story: the median sale price rose 10.5%; new listings increased 13.8%, and average inventory increased 29.4%.
Middle Island, New York housing market statistics for single-family homes, comparing the rolling 12 months through July 2026 with July 2025

📈 Middle Island Market at a Glance

  • Median sale price: $525,000 to $580,000—an increase of 10.5%.
  • New listings: 109 to 124—an increase of 13.8%.
  • Closed sales: 74 to 93—an increase of 25.7%.
  • Average homes for sale: 17 to 22—an increase of 29.4%.
  • Days on market: 47 to 40—7 days faster.
  • Original list price received: 101.0% to 101.7%.

For buyers, higher inventory can give buyers more homes to consider. Middle Island homes took an average of 40 days to sell, 7 days faster than the previous period, while sellers received 101.7% of their original asking price on average. For sellers, the higher median sale price is encouraging, but accurate pricing, condition and presentation remain important.

How is the housing market in Middle Island, New York?

Through July 2026, Middle Island’s rolling 12-month median sale price rose, while new listings increased, closed sales increased and average inventory increased compared with the prior year.

What is the median home price in Middle Island?

The median sale price was $580,000 for the rolling 12 months ending July 2026, up from $525,000 one year earlier.

What does inventory of homes for sale mean?

Inventory is the number of homes available for buyers to choose from. Middle Island averaged 22 homes for sale, compared with 17 during the previous 12-month period.

Are Middle Island homes selling over asking price?

On average, sellers received 101.7% of their original asking price, which is above 100%. An individual result depends on pricing, condition and buyer demand.

Would you like housing market statistics for your town?If you don’t see housing market statistics for your town and would like to have them, let me know which Nassau or Suffolk County community interests you. I’ll provide the latest available local market information.

Request Your Town’s Statistics

Source: OneKey MLS. Rolling 12-month single-family data through July 2026. Statistics describe overall market activity and are not an appraisal of any individual property.