Bay Shore Homes For Sale Featured1 / 21$860,000Single Family Home For SaleActive7BEDS4TOTAL BATHS3,300SQFT1060 Nugent AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â Featured1 / 27$509,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS1557 Heckscher AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â Featured1 / 1$389,000Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS316 Frederick AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â Featured1 / 23$439,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1,842SQFT1439 E Forks RoadBay Shore, NY 11706Â Featured1 / 16$449,990Single Family Home For SalePending5BEDS2TOTAL BATHS2,400SQFT49 Oakland AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â Featured1 / 7$129,990Condo For SalePending1BED1TOTAL BATH5b Hemlock Drive #98Bay Shore, NY 11706Lexington Village SubdivisionFeatured1 / 1$320,000Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS1TOTAL BATH1619 N Gardiner DriveBay Shore, NY 11706Â Open House Sat, Jun 19, 5 PM UTCPlease verify times due to COVID-191 / 33$599,000Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS37 Sunset RoadBay Shore, NY 11706Â Open House Sun, Jun 20, 4 PM UTCPlease verify times due to COVID-191 / 24$424,000Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1,668SQFT1069 Manor LaneBay Shore, NY 11706Â Open House Sat, Jun 19, 2 PM UTCPlease verify times due to COVID-191 / 18$415,000Townhouse For SaleActive3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS57 Jan CourtBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - yesterday1 / 8$150,000Business Opportunity For SaleActiveSUFFOLKCOUNTY124 5th AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â Open House Sun, Jun 20, 4 PM UTCPlease verify times due to COVID-191 / 16$549,000Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1149 Hyman AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - 3 days online1 / 28$399,999Single Family Home For SaleActive2BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1436 Gardiner DriveBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - 4 days online1 / 26$499,990Condo For SaleActive2BEDS3TOTAL BATHS26 Sugar Pine Lane #0Bay Shore, NY 11706Mystic Pines SubdivisionNew Listing - 6 days online1 / 9$369,000Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS1TOTAL BATH1603 N Gardiner DriveBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - a week online1 / 9$459,999Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS140 New York AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - a week online1 / 24$1,149,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS4TOTAL BATHS4,000SQFT35 West LaneBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - a week online1 / 13$2,150,000Condo For SaleActive0.29ACRESSUFFOLKCOUNTY22 Lawrence AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - a week online1 / 29$699,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS3TOTAL BATHS67 West LaneBay Shore, NY 11706Â New Listing - a week online1 / 9$549,000Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS2,000SQFT990 Martinstein AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706Â See all Bay Shore Homes For Sale TweetShareSharePin0 Shares