East Setauket Homes For Sale New Listing - 19 hours online1 / 35$775,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS4TOTAL BATHS6 Buckingham Meadow RoadE. Setauket, NY 11733Island Estates SubdivisionNew Listing - yesterday1 / 36$599,000Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS2,092SQFT8 Cinderella LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Story Book Manor SubdivisionNew Listing - 2 weeks online1 / 36$589,999Condo For SaleActive2BEDS3TOTAL BATHS18 Emilys WayE. Setauket, NY 11733Setauket Meadows SubdivisionNew Listing - 2 weeks online1 / 30$399,000Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS1TOTAL BATH107 Gnarled Hollow RoadE. Setauket, NY 11733Â New Listing - 3 weeks online1 / 18$299,990Single Family Home For SaleActive2BEDS2TOTAL BATHS1,500SQFT11 Pheasant LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Â New Listing - 3 weeks online1 / 19$439,000Single Family Home For SalePending5BEDS2TOTAL BATHS34 Lodge LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Â New Listing - 4 weeks online1 / 26$625,000Condo For SaleActive2BEDS3TOTAL BATHS101 Cove LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Setauket Meadows Subdivision1 / 30$400,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS2TOTAL BATHS7 Possum LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Â Open House Sat, Feb 27, 5 PM UTCPlease verify times due to COVID-191 / 36$699,000Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS2,000SQFT18 Bayview AvenueE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 34$849,999Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS3TOTAL BATHS156 Gnarled Hollow RoadE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 32$648,000Single Family Home For SaleActive5BEDS3TOTAL BATHS3,000SQFT384 Pond PathE. Setauket, NY 11733Â Price Change - 3 weeks ago1 / 35$850,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS5TOTAL BATHS4,800SQFT32 Gnarled Hollow RoadE. Setauket, NY 11733Gnarled Hollow Estates Subdivision1 / 12$519,000Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS4TOTAL BATHS221 Lower Sheep Pasture RoadE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 21$450,000Condo For SaleActive2BEDS3TOTAL BATHS11 Willow Wood DriveE. Setauket, NY 11733Willow Wood Subdivision1 / 12$679,990Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS2,459SQFT10 18 Th StreetE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 21$515,000Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS428 Pond PathE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 20$579,999Single Family Home For SaleActive4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS61 Upper Sheep Past RoadE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 29$449,000Single Family Home For SaleActive3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS24 Pheasant LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 23$449,000Single Family Home For SalePending4BEDS3TOTAL BATHS82 Krispin LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Â 1 / 16$405,000Single Family Home For SalePending3BEDS2TOTAL BATHS47 Bobcat LaneE. Setauket, NY 11733Â See All East Setauket Homes For Sale